Brownies

Overview

Long, skinny East Village bar where Mike Stuto's no-bullshit booking made Brownies one of the two indispensable stops (alongside Mercury Lounge) on the 1990s New York indie-rock touring circuit, hosting early Interpol, Yeah Yeah Yeahs, and the infamous 1998 Fall meltdown before closing in August 2002.

Brownies opened in 1989 as an Irish bar with a small stage at 169 Avenue A, co-founded by Laura McCarthy (who would later also open the Lakeside Lounge). For its first five years the room was unremarkable; its character changed sharply in 1994 when Mike Stuto joined as a booker, parlaying money from a failed A&R stint at Columbia into a partnership (circa 1997–98) and reorienting the calendar around the guitar-band underground then circulating through fanzines and indie labels. The physical room was blunt: a long, narrow bar with the stage at one end and no division between the crowd and the floor, nowhere for label scouts to hide or schmooze, which Stuto's regulars considered a feature. Four bands for six dollars was, by several accounts, a typical bill. The venue became the East Village anchor of a small circuit that also included Mercury Lounge and, for punk-heavier fare, Coney Island High; by the late 1990s almost every significant indie-rock touring act passed through. Brownies' most documented single night came on April 7, 1998, when The Fall played what became a disintegration event: midway through the set, frontman Mark E. Smith grabbed Karl Burns's drumsticks and threw them down; Burns came out from behind the kit and the two fought onstage while bassist Steve Hanley tried to separate them. The row continued at the band's hotel, where police were called and Smith was arrested, reportedly for assaulting keyboardist Julia Nagle, and spent two nights in custody. Burns, Hanley, and guitarist Tommy Crooks quit during the final song and never played with the Fall again. The gig was captured on video and circulates online. In the venue's final years, early Interpol (a frequent booking, per setlist.fm), Yeah Yeah Yeahs, The Strokes, Spoon, Elliott Smith, Bright Eyes, Death Cab for Cutie, Glassjaw, and MF DOOM all appeared on its stage, as did CMJ festival showcases across multiple years. Brownies closed on the night of August 3, 2002, after thirteen years. At the closing, Stuto made remarks from the stage and told the New York Times, 'The music industry has disappointed me for the last 15 years, so maybe it's time I disappoint the music industry.' The live-music infrastructure was stripped from the room but Stuto stayed in the space; by September 2002 it reopened as the HiFi Bar, a music-free venue with a then-remarkable digital jukebox. HiFi itself ran until October 2017, after which the address passed through Coney Island Baby (opened April 2018), East Berlin, and Heaven Can Wait before Lucinda Williams, Laura McCarthy, and Kelley Swindall opened Lucinda's in summer 2025, returning live music to the room McCarthy had opened as Brownies in 1989.